Sylvia Knee High Boot

Wrong description - it's black suede, not leather. No calf circumference info so I had to rely on the photo yet the photo misleads - seem slender, but actually huge. I could stick my whole fist in the extra room. All 3 problems could be easily avoided - if online shopping is the direction Nordstrom wants to push, out up ACCURATE product information. Not doing so means product return which wastes everyone's time, Nordstrom doesn't get the revenue, and no happy customer.

I love these boots - they are modern with the snipped toe, yet still a classic knee high leather boot. I have a wider foot so sized up to a 9 from an 8.5, and have room to add an insole for extra cushion. I wore them for several hours shopping yesterday and they were very comfy for about five hours before my feet started hurting, so I’m counting this as comfy and I assume this will be better once I add in the extra insole. I got several compliments as I walked around the mall yesterday:). I took one star off because they are a little bit saggier than I’d like around the ankles, but that could be because I sized up.

I fell in love with the color and heel of the shoe. It looks very stylish. I was between a 6 and 6.5 but I rarely have to buy a 6.5. I was right to go with the 6. I didn't realize that it only comes in wide calf. They were really uncomfortable when I first put them on. I know Sam Edelman is not really comfortable to me, I thought I could eventually break it in. As for height I think they were just right. I'm 5'1 ; 113 lbs and just came right under my knee so I am safe bending my leg. Unfortunately- I will return them. The color isn't enough to disregard the wide calf and how there is no support to your foot/ ball of foot. For a shoe that is $200 or more, I need it to check all my boxes and I may have to spend more to get better quality/choices. My search continues!

I'm 5'1 and 125 pounds with muscular calves (~14 inch circumference) so it's always a mystery if boots will fit me. These are really pretty, especially the heel design, but there's a few issues for me: 1. They were tight around my calves with tights and no way they would fit with leggings or jeans. 2. The shaft is too tall for my leg length, it lands at a weird part just under my knee. 3. Since the boot is clearly designed for a taller human, the back part of the ankle tapers in too high for me and creates a weird illusion around ankles - not the clean lines i was hoping for. Sadly will be going back. Will probably work better for someone who is taller and with slimmer claves than me.

I’m 5’2” and have big calves (athletic build). I struggle with high knee boots because of my height and athletic legs but not with these boots! They are just perfect. They fit perfect and they’re so comfortable! I’m extremely happy with my purchase and will definitely get them in brown suede as well.

Love them ! Beautiful, soft leather, comfortable and sexy! Got the wide calf and fit just right

These boots are gorgeous and comfortable.I wore them for one night and received tons of compliments. However, I scuffed the heel and whatever material is over the heel part came right off. I was inside a hotel the entire night and never went outdoors, so I have no clue how they got so damaged! Now it’s got a big gash on the heel and I’m afraid it’ll peel even more. So disappointed because they’re gorgeous.

I have long legs for only being 5'5" but these are clearly for much taller ladies. They hit me at an uncomfortable part of my knee. Also, the calves are very wide even though I ordered "regular" sized. They looked like I was wearing large rain boots. I thought based on the pictures, that they would be fitted and slender but instead, they had huge gaps and were wrinkly. Not the look I was going for. Over the years, I have noticed the calf size of boots getting larger and larger so I am stuck with wearing my old boots because it is now hard to find ones that fit. Other than the calf being large, the 7.5 size fit perfectly and that's what I usually wear.

I bought these to go with a short dress I have. Based on measuring my calf while ordering, I went with the wide width. The boot unflatteringly hit at just at the bottom of my kneecap, and the boot stands over an inch off my calf. For reference I am an athletic 5’3” and wear a 28” - 30” inseam. I returned them.

I love these boots and had been waiting for them to restock but was so disappointed when they arrived damaged. I called to see if I could keep them and get a price adjustment and they said my only option was to return but they couldn’t replace because the boot is again out of stock. I also asked if they could notify me when it comes back in stock and they said that wasn’t an option.

They r Suede not leather. Worse, they are not comfortable. My foot looks weirdly long bc the toe/ front is too long.I wear a size 7. going back.

Fit is right, comfy to walk and dance on