XL Lip Liner + Styler Pencil

I bought this liner in the shades Deep Dianthus, Stargazer, and Mauve Dahlia. I tried to pick the coolest (i e., most blue-based) shades on offer and happily, mission accomplished. All three shades are gorgeous. Mauve Dahlia is a beautiful pink-nude shade with the barest hint of shimmer. Deep dianthus and stargazer are great natural pink shades (they're similar, but I'm glad I got both). The formula is very creamy and they all go on satin-easy. They have amazing (might I say insane!) longevity, whether used as just a liner or filling my lips in completely as a lipstick. You get a lot more product with these than with other lip liners. I appreciate that I can roll the stick up & down. Not at all drying. I've been impressed by several of this brand's products, and these are on that list now, too. I swatched the shades on plain white paper and took photos w/ & w/o flash to help other see the three shades I got.