High Volume Mascara

Great mascara-when it is. Love the way it applies, wears and washes off, no smudging or flaking, and long wearing. The problem is you never know what you're going to get in the tube. I have purchaed this mascara repeatedly because I think it is the all around best. When it is full and smooth and "fresh" it can't be beat. However, sometimes when I open a brand new, out of the box tube it is dry and seems not quite full. Have returned several. Someday I will remember to check the tube before I leave the store. When ordering online, it's a gamble. Trish needs to find a fix to make this product consistent. Then it will truly be the "best".

I'm a professional chef, in a hot kitchen every day for long hours. This is the *only* mascara that never runs, never smudges, and lasts all day. I only wish it came in a color other than black - I'm a red head, and a nice rich brown color would be great. It would also be nice if it had a little more "oomph" in terms of lash volume, but really, it's the only thing I wear now, and I'll keep buying it as long as they keep making it.

Whoa. This used to be my most favorite make-up product EVER and holy grail of a mascara. No more! It still comes off as expected for a tubing mascara at the end of the day but that is the only remnant of what used to be an incredible mascara. It flakes, bleeds and no longer builds a thick, long natural looking lash. What used to be a thick, long, luscious mascara that made my lashes look almost like fake eye lashes - this totally disappoints and within the past couple of years has become SOOO over priced! I have used this mascara for easily 20 years but after the past several purchases over the past 2 years - this was my final straw. No more. I actually used to wear all Trish McEvoy products but over the past 10 years - stopped wearing everything except the mascara. Disappointing. Don’t bother with this. Too much money for a product that no longer delivers on its claims.

I'm one of the very few to not like this mascara. I love the polymer concept and the no-smudge factor. However I don't think my lashes look all that great - certainly no better than other department stores brands I've tried (for less money). And I hate taking it off; the polymer gets stuck in my washcloth and my eyelashes come out with the polymer tubes. I won't buy again. Love some of Trish's other products but not this one.

I am frustrated with this product not because of it's performance, but because of the fact that the company is selling a full size mascara (at a high price point) and providing a sample sized quantity. First for the good, I love the color and formula, it defines my lashes and doesn't clump, it is a warm brown and brings out my green eyes without looking like obviously colored mascara, and it washes off easily without any additional product or makeup remover needed. However, Trish McEvoy should be ashamed of the amount of product provided in each tube. There is .18oz of mascara in this tube, by comparison Dior Show has .36oz of product and is slightly less expensive, same for YSL mascara and Charlotte Tilbury. It seems ALL other mascaras in have more than twice as much product as this one does. This is just poor form by the company and I hope they adjust there practices to be more fair and on par with their competition. I would have become a regular buyer of this but do not feel right supporting such obvious scamming on the part of the company.