Skip navigation

The Gift Shop is open! Find perfect picks for everyone on your list. Holiday Gifts

Set Your Store|Set Your ZIP
Main content
  1. Home
  2. Beauty
  3. Makeup
  4. Eyes
(24)24

You're a Gem 3-Piece Eye Makeup Set $88 Value

Too Faced

Sold Out

SOLD OUT

This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.

Details & care

What it is: A dazzling, limited-edition eye-makeup set with an eyeshadow palette, an eyelash primer and a mascara to make every moment sparkle.

Set includes:
- Full-size You're a Gem 5-Shade Eyeshadow Palette
- Full-size Better Than Sex Foreplay Lash Primer (0.27 oz.)
- Full-size Better Than Sex Mascara (0.27 oz.)

Eyeshadow shades include:
- Diamond Fire: icy white with holographic blue shimmer
- Pretty Pampered: misty nude rose matte
- Flashy: electric magenta metallic
- You're a Gem!: warm shimmering silver shimmer
- Treasure Chest: brown matte

How to use: Apply Shadow Insurance Eye Shadow Primer to ensure crease-proof wear. Apply a matte shade from lash line to brow bone using a large shader brush to neutralize the lid. Apply a deeper shade using a fluffy blender brush to sculpt the crease. Blend softly upward and outward to diffuse edges. Apply a shimmer or metallic shade on eyelid using a small shadow brush with a pressing technique. For the richest shimmer payoff, use a fingertip. Apply to lash line for a custom eye liner. Apply Better Than Sex Foreplay Mascara Primer to lashes and allow to dry. Apply Better Than Sex Mascara to complete the look.

  • $88 Value
  • Item #10467881
  • Core Product ID 333333J5WF

Shipping & returns

Free shipping. Free returns. All the time. Purchases made online can also be returned or exchanged at any Nordstrom store, free of charge. Read more about our shipping & returns policies.

Gift options

Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

Too Faced

A serious makeup brand that knows how to have fun, Too Faced is unabashedly pink, pretty and feminine—with a playful wink. Jerrod Blandino and Jeremy Johnson founded the company in 1998, infusing it with a rebellious spirit, visionary focus and unexpected humor that define the brand to this day. Too Faced inspires confidence to experiment and encourages women to "own their pretty."

Reviews

(24)243.8 out of 5
Write a Review

Most helpful positive review

Sept 14, 2023

chocolate lashes has changed the game

I've re-purchased this mascara 3 times now. The brown mascara in my favorite "Better Than Sex" formula is just incredible. It lends a more natural look because the color, but can still get huge beautiful lashes with this formula. Note: I do believe this mascara gets better with time, meaning it needs to dry out a little/be exposed to air before it really starts to perform at its highest potential.
ArtemisCally
Verified purchase
1found this helpful

Most helpful critical review

June 27, 2024

Like tar

I would assign it a score of a zero if I could. It appeared dried out when I received it that there was hardly anything in the container and I had to consistency of asphalt. I didn’t want to put it on my eyelashes would pull my eyelashes out trying to remove it.
DrGFla
Verified purchase
1found this helpful

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars58%
4 stars8%
3 stars8%
2 stars8%
1 star17%
June 27, 2024

Like tar

I would assign it a score of a zero if I could. It appeared dried out when I received it that there was hardly anything in the container and I had to consistency of asphalt. I didn’t want to put it on my eyelashes would pull my eyelashes out trying to remove it.
Verified purchase
DrGFla
Color:
Black
1found this helpful
Sept 14, 2023

chocolate lashes has changed the game

I've re-purchased this mascara 3 times now. The brown mascara in my favorite "Better Than Sex" formula is just incredible. It lends a more natural look because the color, but can still get huge beautiful lashes with this formula. Note: I do believe this mascara gets better with time, meaning it needs to dry out a little/be exposed to air before it really starts to perform at its highest potential.
Verified purchase
ArtemisCally
Size purchased:
0.27 oz
Color:
CHOCOLATE
1found this helpful
Nov 25, 2025

Smelly eye shadow

Had a strange odor triggering a migraine
Reposted from nordstromrack.com
Verified purchase
Julie 46
Oct 10, 2025

You have to get this!

Beautiful! Love it!
Reposted from nordstromrack.com
Verified purchase
Ruby V
Aug 7, 2025

Awful Do not buy

This stuff is seriously so gross - first of all it does NOT come off. You have to scrub your lashes so hard that it damages them and will irratate your eyes. Second I received a bottle that was dried up - I used it once and tried to ask to return and NORDSTROM denied it. Waste of money I threw it away. Will buy my products elsewhere now.
mmeow
Size purchased:
0.13 oz
Color:
Pitch Black
Was this helpful?
June 14, 2025

Thick mascara that builds nicely on fine lashes

I have been using this for years and will be forever. The liquid is thicker than most which is great for me because I have a ton of fine long lashes and it helps them not clump together. You can keep brushing to get everything perfectly separated. I will be so sad if this is ever discontinued. I love the look of the tube too! Not a cheaply made mascara and worth the money. I will say that it does flake a tiny bit if you start messing with it later in the day, but I just try not to touch my eyes and can go the full 12 with it on if I keep my hands away!
Verified purchase
HannaSD
Size purchased:
0.27 oz
Color:
CHOCOLATE
Was this helpful?