Skip navigation

Early Black Friday Sale! Get up to 25% off select styles through 11/11. Restrictions apply. Shop Now

Set Your Store|Set Your ZIP
Main content
  1. Home
  2. Women
  3. Shoes
  4. Flats
  5. Mary Jane
(74)74

The Square Mary Jane

Rothy's

Women

Current Price $100.00
Color
Color: Wren
Customers say the fit runs true to size.
Size
B
12 people viewing now
Free 90-day returns
Sold and shipped by Rothy's, Inc.
Select fulfillment method
$60 off your next purchase—ends Dec. 1! Terms apply. Apply Now

Details & care

What's both timeless and trendy? With a chic square toe and flexible strap, The Square Mary Jane puts a fresh spin on this incredibly comfortable flat.

  • Fits true to size. For best fit, order your regular size.
  • Soft, flexible upper with a smooth toe box.
  • Features a matching slim, flexible strap that keeps your feet secure.
  • Comfortable insoles and durable tortoise shell outsoles.
  • Machine Washable: Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Wear again and again.
  • Knit with Rothy's signature thread, which is spun from recycled plastic bottles.
  • This product was made in Rothy's LEED certified factory, which achieved TRUE Zero Waste certification in 2023, validating that it’s operating with zero-waste practices by diverting solid waste from landfill, incineration and the environment.
  • Item #10442674
  • Core Product ID 333333HC8J
Helpful info:
True to size.

Size info

  • Fits true to size. For best fit, order your regular size.

Shipping & returns

Free shipping—all the time. Learn more about our shipping & returns policies.

This item has a different return policy. Items sold and shipped by Rothy's, Inc. can be returned by mail or to a Nordstrom store within 90 days of when the item shipped and must be in new condition, with tags attached.

Gift options

Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.

Delivery

  • Email gift message (free)
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

Rothy's

It takes courage to be an optimist. To believe anything is possible—and set out on a quest to prove it. Using innovative technology, Rothy's invented a whole new way to turn plastic bottles into comfortable, washable and stylishly sustainable shoes, keeping millions of bottles out of landfills—so far. Here’s to following your own path, one optimistic step at a time. Believe in possible with Rothy's.

Reviews

(74)744.0 out of 5
Write a Review
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide

Most helpful positive review

Dec 2, 2024

true to size

My first pair of Rothy’s. Incredibly soft. Stock with your true size. I went half a size up based on other reviews and thought it fit, it just didn’t feel right. Re-ordered my true size 8 and they fit like a glove. Classy, elegant look. I bought two pairs/colors.
Selle00001
22found this helpful

Most helpful critical review

Dec 10, 2024

DONT BUY THROUGH NORDSTROM

I bought these shoes on sale for $100 on Black Friday. I got them and they are too large because all the reviews say to size up, so I went to exchange them, and Nordstrom has told me I have to pay full price for my exchange since they were shipped by Rothy’s. If they weren’t going to exchangeable I would have loved to know that because now I just have to return them and I can’t afford to rebuy them for $160 and Nordstrom won’t compensate for the additional cost. And Rothy’s has no way of verifying my purchase so they can’t help me. I needed these shoes for work and waited until Black Friday to buy them so that I could afford them. Super disappointed with Nordstrom for their customer service on this one.
Disappointed666666
88found this helpful

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars59%
4 stars14%
3 stars3%
2 stars15%
1 star9%
Dec 10, 2024

DONT BUY THROUGH NORDSTROM

I bought these shoes on sale for $100 on Black Friday. I got them and they are too large because all the reviews say to size up, so I went to exchange them, and Nordstrom has told me I have to pay full price for my exchange since they were shipped by Rothy’s. If they weren’t going to exchangeable I would have loved to know that because now I just have to return them and I can’t afford to rebuy them for $160 and Nordstrom won’t compensate for the additional cost. And Rothy’s has no way of verifying my purchase so they can’t help me. I needed these shoes for work and waited until Black Friday to buy them so that I could afford them. Super disappointed with Nordstrom for their customer service on this one.
Fit: Large
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
7
Width purchased:
B
Usual size:
6
Color:
Black
Disappointed666666
88found this helpful
Dec 12, 2024

do no buy through Nordstrom

The shoes are decent , runs slightly small and narrow. I would recommend purchasing directly thought the Rothy’s website. If you decided to go though Nordstrom just know that if you need to exchange for another size that they will NOT honor any sale pricing you originally purchased at. I was told I had to return the size to got a sale and could only repurchase for the FULL price . Horrible customer service . They said there policy is “they only match sale pricing if you exchange for the same size/color” which defeats the purpose of an exchange
Fit: Runs slightly small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Width purchased:
B
Verified purchase
cantexchange
56found this helpful
Nov 11, 2024

Price does not match quality.

If you have wider feet this is not the shoe for you. A big reason why I sent the pair of shoes back is because you could see the imprint of my toes through the shoe .
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
11
Color:
Wren
admittedshopaholic
37found this helpful
Dec 2, 2024

true to size

My first pair of Rothy’s. Incredibly soft. Stock with your true size. I went half a size up based on other reviews and thought it fit, it just didn’t feel right. Re-ordered my true size 8 and they fit like a glove. Classy, elegant look. I bought two pairs/colors.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8
Width purchased:
B
Color:
Black
Selle00001
22found this helpful
May 12, 2025

Narrow

Purchased in my normal size and I have always been normal in width. I was so hopeful for these flats to work because I struggle so much to find them. These are so narrow and hurt so much. I'll have to return these.
Fit: Runs slightly small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Minny4288
19found this helpful
Dec 12, 2024

Fell for the hype

I will never understand the trend of paint so much for so little. These shoes were ridiculously thin, unsupportive and felt like plastic. What a waste of money and product.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
harry_love
16found this helpful
Aug 18, 2024

comfy versatile flats

I love these Mary Jane’s. I originally listened to the reviews and sized up but exchanged them for my true size. If you have a regular width or narrow foot, I’d say it’s true to size. If you have a wider foot or like your shoes to be a little loose, size up half a size. They are comfortable, work with a ton of outfits, and are washable. I want them in every color!! The only critique I have is that the strap isn’t adjustable so it doesn’t fit snug to my foot.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Width purchased:
B
Verified purchase
teeniek
TOP 1000 REVIEWER
16found this helpful
Aug 1, 2024

So comfortable!

These are my 4th pair of Rothy MJ's. They have been a life saver this summer while I've been dealing with heel pain. Super comfortable and easy to dress up or down. I've worn them with everything from maxi dresses to sweatpants. They do run a half size small so size up. I normally wear 8.5 and a 9 fits perfect!
Fit: Runs slightly small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
9
Width purchased:
B
Usual size:
8.5
Color:
Wren
howright
15found this helpful
Oct 3, 2024

run small

These shoes are so cute I wanted to keep them but they run very small. I even sized up and they were too small. Also the bottom is slippery. There’s a soft pad on the bottom that minimizes the tread so I found myself slipping in my house (hardwood floors) as I was trying them on
Fit: Small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
9
Width purchased:
B
Color:
Wren
ErdS
11found this helpful
June 23, 2025

cute comfy but

slippery soles on surfaces like tile and hardwood.otherwise cute, accomplishes a true navy Mary Jane’s . can’t risk a slippery slide. Soles appear non-skid but they are not.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8
Color:
Deep Navy
CustomerSince1981
10found this helpful
July 19, 2024

so comfy!

Absolutely love these shoes. So comfortable! Ordered half size larger than normal and fit great.
Fit: Runs slightly small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8.5
Width purchased:
B
Color:
Lollipop Red
melmarsh
10found this helpful
Sept 16, 2025

Back of Shoe Digs Into Heel

I really wanted to love these shoes, but the back of the shoe started digging into my heel after only two hours of wear (and not a lot of walking!). This is my first time wearing them, and I can’t imagine what my foot will look like by the end of the day. Very disappointing given the price. Otherwise, the fit is true to size.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
7
Width purchased:
M
Color:
Graphite Black
Elle246
9found this helpful

Outfit Ideas For This Item