The Max Square Mary Jane

I bought into the hype of how comfortable these shoes are . When they arrived I put them on and walked around the house with them for a few hours. I will tell you they have zero support. They were not comfortable whatsoever. I can’t imagine walking around outside with these shoes on for miles or hours. Back they went.

Oh my goodness these shoes were so cute when I got them, but they are so uncomfortable and they hurt the front and the back of my feet when I walk. Bottom too. Basically can’t wear them anymore. I am a size 7 and order to seven then I had to return them and get a 7 1/2. They are still too tight but didn’t want to hustle returning them again by mail since I had an event to attend I needed them.

I am a 5 or 5.5 and got the 5.5. I’m mostly a 5 so that’s why I said it ran a bit small. If your feet aren’t wide they’d be perfect. I have wide feet and they’re still comfortable. The insole is more cushiony than my other Rothy’s it but does make for a slightly tighter fit. Pricey but I got them because they’re washable. It’s the only reason I chose pink. Nice pale pink color. Wonder how long the strap will keep its shape because it’s stretchy. Trying them out around the house and I don’t feel any rubbing so far.

I love these and purchased them in the fuzzy black as well. However, they run ridiculously small. Comically small. I’m normally a 8-8.5 I ordered a 8.5 and they were too small. I got a 9 but really could have even did a 9.5 or 10. That’s shocking but the sizing is off. I don’t find them overly comfortable either. They are simply cute and that’s why I’m writing the review. They are adorable