Shine Eye Shade Refill

I was buying the small palette and was going to pick up a couple of colors. Based on a previous review of "malachite", I decided to try that color. Our coloring is about the same, and anybody buying that many items at one time on the outside chance it might be discontinued had to have something. I wish I could thank her, because she is absolutely right. I was scared to death when I saw it in the pan because it looks almost black. When you get it on - takes practice and the right brush to get it light enough - it seems to be the perfect color! It looks neither blue, nor green, but is such a better option for eyes that have a little of both colors. Nothing else I have tried has looked this natural. I may have to order back-ups as well. I agree about the shine being unlike most frosted shades. I've been looking for matte shades, but these are better. There is a lot of product in each pan. I have had the big palette for years and each pan lasts and lasts. I can't tell you how long it lasts because the make-up police would be knocking on my door because I have had it too long.