Name: Madison Penny Loafer
Brand: Peter Millar
Price: 350.00 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.3 (7 reviews)

Details & care

Crafted in Brazil, this sleek loafer brings modern versatility to a time-honored silhouette. Shaped in natural-grain tumbled calf leather with a soft almond toe, it showcases the hide’s subtle variations so no two look exactly alike. Bologna construction delivers exceptional flexibility with a glove-like feel underfoot while a rubber sole adds steady traction and lasting durability.

Leather upper and lining/rubber sole
Made in Brazil
Item #10981409
Core Product ID 333333ZZ8C

Size info

True to size.

Shipping & returns

Free shipping. Free returns. All the time. Purchases made online can also be returned or exchanged at any Nordstrom store, free of charge. Read more about our shipping & returns policies.

Gift options

Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.

Delivery

Email gift message (free)

Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.

Shop Gifts

Peter Millar

Peter Millar launched in 2001 with a single cashmere sweater, which embodied a commitment to craftsmanship that continues today. Now offering a complete range of casual apparel and sportswear, the brand works with only the finest materials and quality fabrics sourced from specialist mills and workshops.

Reviews

(7)74.3 out of 5

Write a Review

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

Show reviews with 5 stars

5 stars71%

Show reviews with 4 stars

4 stars0%

Show reviews with 3 stars

3 stars14%

Show reviews with 2 stars

2 stars14%

Show reviews with 1 star

1 star0%

Verified Purchases

Sept 2, 2026

Madison Penny Loafer

Fits true to size. Great looking shoe with jeans or chinos. As for pricing, I expect them to last longer than my shoes which are 1/2 the price.

Reposted from petermillar.com

Verified purchase

Todd

Sept 1, 2026

Love the shoe

Great looking shoe for dress or casual! Very comfortable and fits just the same as all other Peter Millar shoes I have and I have about eight pairs! I wear a size 11 in medium width!

Reposted from petermillar.com

Jack

July 30, 2026

Per fit.

Took advice and bought one size up and shoes are a perfect fit. I have a C/D width, Normally wear an 11.5 Shoe D shoe. Blue loafer.

Reposted from petermillar.com

Mike

Mar 10, 2026

Great Shoes!

Perfect Shoe. Highly recommend. Fits beautifully. Comfortable and appropriate for all occasions. I wish they came in black as well!

Reposted from petermillar.com

Verified purchase

Martin

Feb 20, 2026

A Sad Replacement for the Previous Loafers

These are alright but they’re nothing like the well constructed previous style that were much more comfortable, allowed for the insertion of my arthritis insoles, and felt stable. So the search continues for their replacement as these are not the ones.

Reposted from petermillar.com

petermillar.com response

Thank you for your feedback on this product. We are so sorry to hear that you are not completely satisfied with this Loafer. We value all customer reviews, and have forwarded this information to our product development team. Over the years, our design team continually works to refine and improve our items based on customer feedback, changes in fashion trends, and advancements in technology. As a result, you may notice some differences from past seasons or season to season. We understand that these changes can sometimes be surprising, and we appreciate your understanding as we work to provide you with the best possible fit and experience. If you have any further feedback, please reach out to us at concierge@petermillar.com.

RNull

Feb 13, 2026