Skip navigation

End-of-Season Clearance: up to 50% off summer styles from your favorite brands. Sale

Main content
  1. Home
Carmel Lug Penny Loafer video
(16)16

Carmel Lug Penny Loafer

Paul Green

Sold Out

SOLD OUT

This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.

Details & care

A supple suede upper and cushioned footbed lend comfortable softness to this Italian-made penny loafer boosted on a grippy platform lug sole.

  • 1 1/4" platform
  • Cushioned footbed
  • Leather upper and lining/synthetic sole
  • Made in Italy
  • Item #10748906
  • Core Product ID 333333SSRT

Size info

  • The brand says this runs true to size.
    Shoe packaging reflects U.K. sizing.

Shipping & returns

Free shipping. Free returns. All the time. Purchases made online can also be returned or exchanged at any Nordstrom store, free of charge. Read more about our shipping & returns policies.

Gift options

Choose your gift options at Checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

Paul Green

Since its launch in 1988, women's shoe company Paul Green has strived to combine beautiful looks with exceptional comfort. The brand's fashion formula has always been equal parts elegance and sportiness, and its shoes are manufactured in Europe to last a lifetime. Paul Green shoes are fun to buy, to wear, to own and to show off—day after day after day.

Reviews

(16)164.3 out of 5
Write a Review
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide

Most helpful positive review

Sept 14, 2025

Versatile Loafer with style and comfort!

I love a cute loafer! Paul Green always makes a great shoe with style and comfort. I wear this brand often and this shoe is true to width and size! It has a soft sole and a great cushioned insole! The appearance and design achieve a visual look of a narrow shoe but slip them on and they are fabulous! I have a small foot that is more wide than narrow with a high metatarsal and the shoe is very comfortable. Maybe size up if you wear between a 6 or 6.5.
nordsrom
2found this helpful

Most helpful critical review

Sept 3, 2025

Hate Then, Now Can't Return

I absolutely hate these shoes. After one day, they have given me blisters. I thought they would work when trying them on in the store, but after an hour of use, they are too snug. I feel cheated. I didn't realize Nordstrom's return policy changed from their fantastic service from long ago. I now have $400+ shoes that I am miserable in. I told myself could spend more to get comfort. Now I can't afford anything else and have to suffer. What a costly mistake.
KerrieD
Verified purchase
12found this helpful

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars69%
4 stars6%
3 stars13%
2 stars6%
1 star6%
Sept 3, 2025

Hate Then, Now Can't Return

I absolutely hate these shoes. After one day, they have given me blisters. I thought they would work when trying them on in the store, but after an hour of use, they are too snug. I feel cheated. I didn't realize Nordstrom's return policy changed from their fantastic service from long ago. I now have $400+ shoes that I am miserable in. I told myself could spend more to get comfort. Now I can't afford anything else and have to suffer. What a costly mistake.
Fit: Small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
11.5US / 9UK
Usual size:
11.5US / 9UK
Color:
Black Suede
Verified purchase
KerrieD
12found this helpful
Sept 18, 2025

Beautifully made shoe - Runs big

The shoe is beautifully made and looks good on. I am a solid 9.5 and this shoe was too large by a half size. I have a narrowish foot and the heel space was very wide.
Fit: Runs slightly large
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly wide
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
9.5US / 7UK
Usual size:
9.5US / 7UK
Color:
BLACK SUEDE
Verified purchase
Clintina
8found this helpful
Oct 1, 2025

PG Shrunk the Foot Mold

I have 3 pairs of PG loafers, all size 4.5. These are easily 1cm narrower in the toe box and very loose in the heel. Same with the new PG boots I tried and returned. If this new fit is for all future designs, PG lost a customer.
Fit: Runs slightly large
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Verified purchase
Vixmo
4found this helpful
Sept 14, 2025

Versatile Loafer with style and comfort!

I love a cute loafer! Paul Green always makes a great shoe with style and comfort. I wear this brand often and this shoe is true to width and size! It has a soft sole and a great cushioned insole! The appearance and design achieve a visual look of a narrow shoe but slip them on and they are fabulous! I have a small foot that is more wide than narrow with a high metatarsal and the shoe is very comfortable. Maybe size up if you wear between a 6 or 6.5.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
6US / 3.5UK
Color:
Earth Soft Suede
nordsrom
2found this helpful
Jan 27, 2026

Runs bigger than other Paul Green shoes

Nice shoe but too big. Always wear size 4 in PG. These are easily one size too big. Heel is wide for my foot. Not sure sizing down will help. Otherwise a very nice shoe.
Fit: Runs slightly large
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Verified purchase
braincandy
1found this helpful
Sept 27, 2025

beautiful shoes but too big

Fit: Large
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8.5US/ 6UK
Usual size:
8.5US/ 6UK
Color:
Black Suede
Verified purchase
schiffer
1found this helpful