Miller Reserve Penny Loafer (Men)

Great looking loafer that actually fits! Been searching for a good fit in a penny loafer for years - something that fits like a pair of J&Ms I had back in the 80s. I wear a 10.5 B in almost every AE shoe I have but never had luck with the loafers. Randolph and Patriot both are loose and require a pad under the tongue/vamp and a 10B is too short. Other styles have come and gone and never worked either. The Miller is perfect and fits right out of the box. I hate it that they cost so much and don't seem notably better finished than other AE cordovan shoes I own, but for the fit, it's worth it. And I doubt I'll ever need another pair of loafers considering how long a shoe like this will last. That they fit me this well may mean that those who get a good fit out of the other AE loafer styles may need to size up. But for me, they are as good as it gets.