Since 1935, Trotters has been dedicated to high-quality women's footwear with appealing looks and exceptional comfort. The company's first shoes were moccasins made by Native American craftspeople in Old Town, Maine, where the company still has a distribution center. Today, Trotters shoes are offered in extended sizes and widths and are made with the softest leathers, high-tech cushioning and flexible soles.
I'm usually an 8.5W in Trotters, but this shoe in that size fit very small. My toes hit the end of the shoe (so the shoe is shorter than it should be) and while my wide foot did fit in the shoe, the edges of my feet were hanging over the sole of the shoe. It was odd. Returning. Sad, too, because the shoe is cute.
Fit: Small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8.5
Width purchased:
W
Usual size:
8.5
Color:
Black
TooSmallBlazer
5found this helpful
Dec 28, 2023
Finally, A Shoe That Fits Well - and Looks Good
A really nice, dressy shoe with slacks. And it fits well. I only wish it had a little more cushioning in the sole - I would not like to walk long distances in this shoe. I would buy it again, however, as it is otherwise a good fit for my hard-to-fit foot.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8.5 W
Width purchased:
w
Color:
black
Verified purchase
Feleena
5found this helpful
Mar 17, 2024
Too wide in heel for narrow shoe
Too wide in heel
Width: Runs slightly wide
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
10-1/2
Verified purchase
Cindy
3found this helpful
Nov 8, 2022
Great Shoe!
Fits well and very comfortable! Easy to care for. Looks great with slacks and jeans.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Verified purchase
sue H2oson
Height:
5’2”
Weight:
125 lb.
3found this helpful
Dec 11, 2024
Good quality shoe
I love the look and comfort. But for being wide they were still a bit narrow in the toe area. It's the only reason it wasn't a 5.
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Runs slightly narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
12 W
Width purchased:
Wide
Color:
Black
Verified purchase
Armida D
2found this helpful
Oct 8, 2024
Great dress flats!
So hard to find a true flat shoe that is super comfortable AND dressy! These are perfect!
Fit: True to size
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
8.5
Width purchased:
wide
Color:
Black
Verified purchase
Terri N
2found this helpful
Jan 5, 2026
Poor design/fit
I tried this cute Trotter's oxford style, the Lizzie Derby Flat, in Burgundy in size 12M. My feet officially measure just long enough to be an 11.5, and my measured width is slightly narrow, but usually a medium is fine for me. I prefer shoes with amazing arch support and enough stiffness through the mid foot to counteract my overpronation tendencies.
This shoe fits like a roomy size 11M or maybe a tight 11.5M, it's definitely not a US-standard size 12M.
The construction of the shoe features an elongated midsole and short, narrow, tapered almond-shape toe box, with a block 1/2" heel. On the foot, these shoes slightly resemble baguettes due to lack of shaping for the arch; and there is no noticeable shaping of the mid foot (from above). The interior opening rubs against skin just below the ankle (interior). Socks are advised, or use some foam tape for comfort. Arch support is minimal. The forefoot sole is flexible, but the mid foot is firm. The interior sole lining could potentially be torn out an replaced with your choice of insert, but this shoe fits too snuggly to support the addition of a traditional (i.e. thick) orthotic, unless, perhaps, you can size up. The heel counter is manmade and attached, along with the sole, with glue only, and I'm not sure how long the soles/heels will last or if they can be repaired once the soles start to wear out. I prefer repairable shoes over cheaper throw-aways.
Fit: Small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: Narrow
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
12
Width purchased:
M
Usual size:
12, 11
Color:
Burgundy
Verified purchase
Shimr
1found this helpful
Dec 10, 2023
Sizing concern
Length is a bit too long and the width is a bit too tight.
Verified purchase
Di B
1found this helpful
Nov 18, 2023
Run short
Great shoe loved the style but they ran short so I have to return them
Fit: Runs slightly small
Small
True to size
Large
Width: True to width
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Size purchased:
9N
Width purchased:
Narrow
Color:
Black
Verified purchase
SuzanELise
1found this helpful
June 23, 2023
A classy return
Classy but returned because looks like a man shoe.
Verified purchase
NikkyDz
1found this helpful
Jan 19, 2023
Fit
Looks nice, but have to return for fit -- too short.