True Mary Jane Pump

I ordered these last minute hoping they wouldn’t give me blisters because I needed to wear them all-day, 4 days straight. They we so comfortable. I wasn’t expecting them to feel so soft!! They are the PERFECT pair of Mary James! I wear a size 9 and have a normal sized width. Even wearing them thick socks worked!

The wide width is not wide. It's just a regular width which means the regular must be super narrow. Do not purchase if you truly have wide feet. Returning.

Ordered 7.5 medium but width runs narrow. I’m going to order wide and see if that fits better

So cute. I wear a 7.5 and that size fit perfectly. The only issue I have with the shoe is the inside of the shoe is white. The white shows in the arch area of the shoe. I used a black sharpie to color that in. So far so good.

Love the look and color. My feet are between W and WW. The tops goi g over the toe area is too small. More like a regular there.

I really wanted to love these. The Dark Cherry color is gorgeous and the classic Mary Jane style is exactly what I was looking for, but the actual shoe missed the mark on two fronts. First, sizing: I ordered an 8W and they fit more like a 9. There's no way to size down given they already run wide, so I'm stuck with shoes that don't hug my foot the way a Mary Jane should. If you're between sizes, order down. Second, the stiffness is a real problem. I expected some break-in period, but these are rigid across the vamp and around the strap in a way that's made them uncomfortable to wear for more than an hour or two. A shoe like this should have some give from the start, especially at this price point. The look is there — the comfort and construction aren't. Hoping they soften up with wear, but as of now I can't recommend buying true to size.