Melissa Button 2 Knee High Boot

I had my eye on these boots for a good 2 months, and after reading the reviews of how others could barely get their foot into the boot and the very narrow shaft, I was pretty much expecting to be returning them as soon as I received them. I took a chance and ordered them anyway because I could not find another boot that I liked as much as these, and I'm so glad I did! Let me tell you, I do not have skinny legs/calves by any means and the extended calf slipped on so perfectly and easily, and absolutely no struggle to get them on. They have handy little pull tabs on the insides as well to make it easier to get them on. I have slightly wide feet, and I went a half size up, I am normally a 9 or 9 1/2 in boots and I got the 10 Extended Calf. There is still a bit of room in the toe for thicker socks. My calves measure exactly 15 1/4 and there is still room for leggings and jeans with the boot on. They even feel like they will stretch and conform to be even more comfortable with thicker pants, even though they are already so comfy the way they are. Getting them off isn't as difficult as I anticipated either, best if you scrunch the shaft down a bit and then shimmy them off your heels. If you are on the fence about ordering these boots, I'd say it's definitely worth trying them out! I can see how these would def be tighter on someone with a 16"+ calf size, esp without a zipper, so if you do have super thick legs prob not the right boot. But it's definitely not just for people with very skinny legs/calves because they fit me like a dream! Keep in mind this style of leather boot is meant to be broken in and stretched to conform to your feet and legs and over time they fit even better. Can't wait to wear mine in, these are my new favorite boots!