Charm Flat

I’m not sure I’ll keep these. The catus clay color matches a lot of the green in my fall line up. However, the suede looks like it won’t hold up well. I wear a 7.5W. I went up a half size. The last design is just a touch narrow. 50/50 on keeping.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I think I found the perfect loafer! As I pulled them out of the box, I thought, oh no, these are going to be too slim (for my wide feet), but they fit perfectly and are very comfortable. There's some nice cushioning on the bottom, rubbery soles that I hope will last, and don't slip off my heels (a common problem). These aren't really designed for all-day walking/touring, but so nice for a day or evening in town. And I loooove the beautiful olive green color and soft suede. Just a lovely, easy shoe for styling up a bit.

These are not comfortable shoes. The sides are stiff and hit right on the bottom of my ankle bone. Even with trying to break them in, the sides are no less still and they also give me significant heel blisters because the inside of the shoe heel is rough. They are exactly my size, but the material and shape of the sides makes them uncomfortable. Their sole cushioning is minimal. After trying to break them in, I didn't return them due to wear. I didn't want to waste money, so I found they are okay enough to wear with socks if I'm sitting at my desk - but it was hard to find socks that would barely be seen while still protecting my feet. They are pretty shoes but, I'm disappointed. At this price point, I expected more. I did buy the hippie slip ons, which is a slightly different shoe from Naturalizer, and their quality and comfort is well worth the price.

Good all around black flat. Easy to wear with skinny/thin jeans or work outfit.

The sizing on these feels off. Typically a wide in Naturalizer fits and feels great, but not lately. And there is little or no support in these. I am returning them.