Kisha Waterproof Penny Loafer

I really wanted to love these loafers. They're waterproof! And I was particularly looking for a brown suede lugs sole loafer, and this is certainly that. While the fit was fine - comfortable, not stiff, and roomy in the toe area although little wide at the heel for me (this happens in all shoes, and it was nothing a heel insert couldn't fix) - this was the heaviest shoe I've ever worn! It felt like I was wearing Frankenstein shoes; it was impossible to walk without clopping about like a horse. I couldn't see myself walking far at all in such heavy shoes. So I had to return.

I normally wear a 9.5 but have never had a pair of loafers before so maybe that is why I am a 9 in these. If you have a narrow heal, I'd go a size down instead of what they recommend. With a heal pad I can wear them with no socks or thin socks. They are so cute and decently comfy despite being a tighter fit.