Newman Penny Loafer

very nice shoe, would recommend to anyone that loves a traditional penny loafer.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Love the color-Antique Burgundy. I wear a 10 1/2 and ordered the D (normal) width. My first impression is that the length was fine but the normal width is a bit too wide for my feet. There was no option available to purchase a narrower size. I have heard that this may not be a problem after the sole gets more broken in. They look great with my casual work attire.

Unlike other reviewers I had no issue with the fit: I'm a 9.5 medium with and these fit fine. Where I do have to agree is with the comfort/flexibilty of the leather: these shoes are as stiff as cardboard and after months I still have not been able to break them in.

I normally go down a size for loafers, and it definitely took a minute to break them in, but they are the go to...excellent color. The leather is excellent, and I can dress them up or down.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Finish was great, and craftsmanship was great. I will be purchasing another pair soon

After 3 weeks with this shoe, I have to say I am disappointed. The break-in appears to be impossible. The leather remains very stiff and uncomfortable where the edges contact my feet and ankles. The fit remains very loose, so much so that I have had to use aftermarket pads to keep them on in hopes of achieving a better fit. I have many pairs of AEs, and these do not fit as I have come to expect.