Jan 6, 2026
Great concept, didn't quite deliver
I used to live in NYC, so I know a good black and white cookie when I eat one. This basket of cookies looks generous in the description and photos, but it arrived at my doorstep a little on the thin side. The tray was completely filled, but the numbers were clearly fewer than promised. 16 black and white cookies? There were 10. 13 chocolate chip cookies? There were 10. The cookie type that matched the numbers was the hamentaschen with 8. I guess the company decided to charge customers the same price for the older amount of product while quietly downsizing. I haven't tried every treat in the tray yet, but everything looks fresh and delicious.
Verified purchase
FrantzF
- Size purchased:
- One Size
- Color:
- None
3found this helpful