The Chunky Knit Cardigan

I loved the style of this sweater...slightly oversized but cropped. I ordered the grey and brown both in my size M (5'4, 135). I did an in store pickup and went to try them on. First I tried the grey. Perfection. It hit me slightly longer than shown, right at the top of the waistband of my jeans. Sleeves hit as shown. I almost didn't bother trying the brown, but so glad I did. It fit at least 2 sizes bigger...like an XL. Huge! I thought maybe they sent the wrong size, but no. Length was about 6 inches longer. Hands completely covered by the sleeves. Crazy! Returned the brown.