SOLD OUT
This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.
Details & care
What it is: A best-selling waterproof dual-purpose Smudge Stick that can be used as a classic pencil eyeliner or a smudgy eyeshadow.
What it does: Available in an array of gorgeous shades and finishes, Smudge Stick features a cocktail of moisturizer ingredients that ensure color glides on smoothly without tugging, pulling, fading or budging.
How to use: If using as an eyeliner, trace along your upper and lower lashes. For an eyeshadow, use your fingers to smudge out the color before it sets. Smudge Stick does not need a sharpener, however the propel pencil design does not retract.
- 0.01 oz.
- Item #585948
Gift options
Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.
Delivery
- Email gift message (free)
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Stila
Founded in 1994 by makeup artist Jeanine Lobell, Stila makes runway-ready looks more accessible for every day. Committed to its goal of inspiring women to express their authenticity through makeup, Stila offers blendable hues, moisture-rich textures and easy-to-use applicators to help women achieve a makeup-artist finish at home.
Most helpful positive review
Feb 12, 2016
Graphite
I love graphite color! It's very dark grey without being completely black. It makes for a very natural look. Glides on easily and stays on all day. most importantly, the applicator works well- one to two twists to advance and no breakage or crumbling of the pencil. Will keep coming back for more colors.
StyleHunt
8found this helpful
Most helpful critical review
Aug 9, 2013
First & last time I'll buy this
I'm disappointed in this liner, because, once again, I fell for the marketing and now I'm short $20.00. I always spend a lot of time on my eye make-up - and I'm ok with that, but I won't start getting up early to get a good, thin line. There isn't any structure to the liner and that leaves me with a very thick, misshapen line. I spend so much time I don't have correcting the mess - no, it's not worth it (no matter what the cost) and I won't be buying it again.I can't believe they refer to it as "a convenient proper pencil." One other comment: the "sparkle" you hear of is only visible at the end of the day when washing your face! I can get a better product with much less aggrivation at a local pharmacy a few streets away. Once I'm done with this, that's it - never again.
IrishPassport
18found this helpful
5 stars
55%
4 stars
21%
3 stars
9%
2 stars
4%
1 star
10%
Sort by Most Helpful
IrishPassport
Aug 9, 2013
First & last time I'll buy this
I'm disappointed in this liner, because, once again, I fell for the marketing and now I'm short $20.00. I always spend a lot of time on my eye make-up - and I'm ok with that, but I won't start getting up early to get a good, thin line. There isn't any structure to the liner and that leaves me with a very thick, misshapen line. I spend so much time I don't have correcting the mess - no, it's not worth it (no matter what the cost) and I won't be buying it again.I can't believe they refer to it as "a convenient proper pencil." One other comment: the "sparkle" you hear of is only visible at the end of the day when washing your face! I can get a better product with much less aggrivation at a local pharmacy a few streets away. Once I'm done with this, that's it - never again.
18found this helpful
StyleHunt
Feb 12, 2016
Graphite
I love graphite color! It's very dark grey without being completely black. It makes for a very natural look. Glides on easily and stays on all day. most importantly, the applicator works well- one to two twists to advance and no breakage or crumbling of the pencil. Will keep coming back for more colors.
8found this helpful
Flightsgirl
Feb 18, 2015
Truly Waterproof
I have been searching for the perfect waterproof black eyeliner and I finally found it. The stila eye pen liner truly stays put and doesn't smear even through a long workday. I highly recommend it for anyone who gets frustrated with pencils that fade or smear. I'm happy that I finally found an eyeliner that stays put and is easy to use.
6found this helpful
sarahsekai
Dec 31, 2013
stays put on upper lid-slight smudge on lower lid
I purchased the shade Lionfish and it's a great bronzy finish for my brown eyes. I have normal to oily lids so to each their own. When applied to the upper lid, it stayed put but the bottom lid had slight smudging during the 10+ hours on my eyes. When blending with a smudge brush to combine with an eyeshadow color, it collabed well. I use makeup wipes to remove eye makeup and this was easy to remove (thumbs up). The automatic liner is convenient too.
6found this helpful
granmom4
May 17, 2013
staying power
I normally don't use waterproof products around the eye area but was so pleased with Stila eyeshadows that I thought I would try this one. I loved the ease of application and staying power but...after 3 days of my eyes tearing and wiping off most of my eye makeup, I gave up and returned it. What a loss. I would love to be able to use it.
6found this helpful
claire219
Sept 17, 2014
Stays on
I love this eyeliner. I have lionfish, which is a pretty, copper-y brown, and espresso, which I don't see listed here. Both last well, although the lionfish wears off a bit quicker. That said, they last all day, and almost make it through a sweaty spin class. The metallic shades can be a bit dry after a few months.
5found this helpful