




Current Price $450.00
Color: Black
Customers say the fit runs true to size.
Size
Width
Free returns anytime
Sold by Nordstrom
Details & care
An icon since it first landed on mid-century college campuses, this sleek penny loafer features handsome welted construction in earthy leather. Allen Edmonds has been making shoes in America for nearly 100 years using fine leathers, a 212-step crafting process and 360° Goodyear welt construction to allow for recrafting to extend the life of the shoe.
- 360º welt construction for stability and durability
- Leather upper, lining and sole
- Made in the USA
- Item #126721
Size info
- Width equivalents: B{narrow}, C{narrow medium}, D{medium}, E{wide}, EEE{extra wide}.
Shipping & returns
Free shipping. Free returns. All the time. Purchases made online can also be returned or exchanged at any Nordstrom store, free of charge. Read more about our shipping & returns policies.
Gift options
Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.
Free Pickup
- Printed gift message (free)
- Nordstrom gift box (free)
- Fabric gift bag ($5)
Delivery
- Email gift message (free)
- Printed gift message (free)
- Fabric gift bag ($5)
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Allen Edmonds
Allen Edmonds has been creating timeless footwear in the U.S. since 1922. Today, the quality-obsessed shoe and accessories brand continues to produce exquisite styles using an impressively thorough 212-step process. With a focus on enduring fashion and unparalleled comfort, shoes are meticulously crafted from durable materials and available in a wide range of sizes and widths.
Most helpful positive review
Apr 22, 2011
The Great American Shoe
I have been wearing AE shoes for over twenty five years. I got my first pair of AE wing tips with my first good paying job out of college. I still remember how much I paid for them, a lot of money, but after a while I had several pair, and then I became a dedicated fan.
The cool thing about AE is that when the shoes get beat up, but you love them so much you can't stand to toss them away, you send them back to the factory in Wisconsin for re-furbishing. About a $100 later, you have an almost new pair of shoes back to wear for another year or two.
I bought this style last year in black. They work well with pin stripes, dress slacks or jeans. If you have never owned a pair of AE shoes, and these are your first, I suggest you try them on at a store to get your size and best fit. Once you have that down, their shoes are a pretty consistent fit and you are good to go for life!
JDouglas
1found this helpful
Most helpful critical review
Oct 28, 2025
Poor fit
Poor quality, poor craftsmanship, poor construction , low quality materials.
Ali A
Verified purchase
Reposted from allenedmonds.com
allenedmonds.com response
We're very sorry to learn of your disappointment with the Randolph Penny Loafer, but we appreciate your feedback. Your comments have been forwarded to the appropriate team for consideration. If you need further assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our Consumer Care Department. You can find our contact information here: https://www.allenedmonds.com/help/contact-us.
5 stars
65%
4 stars
13%
3 stars
8%
2 stars
6%
1 star
7%
Pros:
Cons:
Sort by Most Helpful
Size
Color
Width
LoveOfNordstrom
Verified purchase
Size purchased: 14D
Fit:
Small
True to size
Large
Width:
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Color: DK CHILI
Aug 10, 2022
Stunning shoe, but sizing is off
I bought my fiancé this shoe in both a size 15 and 14 D. He has two pairs of Allen Edmond Park Avenues in size 15 and LOVES them. He raves about how comfortable they are so I made sure I got him a pair of these from the anniversary sale. Originally I got the size 15, but they were flopping off. So, I ordered him the 14 and they ended up being way too small, so small he couldn’t put them on his foot. Unfortunately, I had to return both shoes. Such a disappointment because they are so nice in person. If you can get a pair that fits you well, definitely keep them.
3found this helpful
Nedley
Fit:
Small
True to size
Large
Width:
Narrow
True to width
Wide
July 1, 2010
Very versatile loafer
Just make sure to order a size down, as with all Allen Edmonds. Very high quality, very comfortable after short break-in period. May pinch a bit at the tongue if you have high arches, but should stretch there too.
2found this helpful
JDouglas
Fit:
Small
True to size
Large
Width:
Narrow
True to width
Wide
Apr 22, 2011
The Great American Shoe
I have been wearing AE shoes for over twenty five years. I got my first pair of AE wing tips with my first good paying job out of college. I still remember how much I paid for them, a lot of money, but after a while I had several pair, and then I became a dedicated fan.
The cool thing about AE is that when the shoes get beat up, but you love them so much you can't stand to toss them away, you send them back to the factory in Wisconsin for re-furbishing. About a $100 later, you have an almost new pair of shoes back to wear for another year or two.
I bought this style last year in black. They work well with pin stripes, dress slacks or jeans. If you have never owned a pair of AE shoes, and these are your first, I suggest you try them on at a store to get your size and best fit. Once you have that down, their shoes are a pretty consistent fit and you are good to go for life!
1found this helpful
Navi
Reposted from allenedmonds.com
Verified purchase
May 12, 2026
Something that fits perfectly
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I had looking for months an affordable and quality pair of loafers and I finally found one. They are 1/2 longer (not bigger) than my regular loafers. Other than that, great loafer!
Sixed
Reposted from allenedmonds.com
Verified purchase
May 10, 2026
Great value. Supple fit.
I wasn’t sure as these were my first AE but decided to give it a try based on the first sale. I’m a regular buyer of Carmina and Crockett and Jones and honestly wasn’t expecting something this good.
morganfrederick
Reposted from allenedmonds.com
May 4, 2026
Nice look but uncomfortable upper
Really an uncomfortable shoe. I have worn it more than a dozen days now and waited for it to break in but it seems to get more uncomfortable, very tight on top of the foot and very rigid leather. I owned a predecessor of this shoe, another AE loafer and was my favorite shoe for years but nothing like this. Perhaps the shape doesn't fit my foot since other reviews here are pretty good or maybe the quality just isn't what it used to be.
allenedmonds.com response
Thank you for providing a review of the Randolph Penny loafers, we are sorry to hear they have caused you discomfort, we will forward your feedback to the appropriate parties for review. If you have any questions or need any assistance with your order, please let us know.
Outfit Ideas For This Item
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling
- Outfit idea created by nordstromstyling.Created by nordstromstyling






























