High Potency Classics Hyaluronic Intensive Moisturizer

I started using this face cream back in January. The very next day, my cheeks began to feel hot; by the third day, they were not only burning but also turning red. Naively, I didn't realize the severity of the situation at the time, assuming my skin just needed a little time to adjust. A few days later, I discovered that my entire face was covered in a dense rash—bumpy to the touch—with my cheeks being particularly affected. I was terrified. I immediately stopped using the cream, and two months later, my skin had returned to being smooth, aside from some lingering redness and minor hyperpigmentation. I wanted to verify once and for all whether this cream was indeed the culprit. So yesterday, I applied a different brand of cream—one I had used previously—to the left side of my face, while applying *this* cream to my right cheek. Sure enough, the burning sensation and redness have now returned to my right cheek. It seems this cream truly isn't suitable for me—but what should I do with the rest of the jar?