Mukluks Tamarack Waterproof Genuine Shearling Boot (Women)

This we a birthday gift to myself and it didn't disappoint. I usually wear an 8 wide shoe or an 8.5 medium and I purchased a 9 as it was recommended to size up. The boots are a tad loose in the heel and across the top of the boot but snug across the toes without a sock. I plan to wear a sock, so I will keep the 9. The leg is fairly wide with a slight slouchy look and the quality is excellent. The insole is not removable as far as I can tell. If you want a snug feel, like UGGs, you have to size down but the 8 will be tight, the Manitobah site claims they will stretch. My feet freeze easily in snug boots so I will stick with the 9. I wish Nordstrom carried the tobacco color because I am very pleased with the black and would invest in another pair.