Aqua Resist Color Eyeliner Pencil

I used makeup forever eyeliner for years. I changed about 8 months ago, tried another brand. I liked it, but not as much. I ordered a new pencil and either something changed or I developed an allergy ! I had used it before, probably 8 years or so, and it does stay put, the black more so than the brown.

Great liner! Goes on so smoothly and stays on! Love the color!!

Best waterproof eye pencil out there! shades are lovely & it so easy to apply. I love the shimmery shades.

My main complaint is that this does not twist up. It works but you only get to use what you see.

I never leave makeup reviews, but this eyeliner is absolutely worth mentioning! This pencil is incredible. This is the first eyeliner I’ve ever used that truly lasts all day without smudging, fading, or coming off. I even got my daughter hooked on it, and she is ranting and raving about how she finally doesn’t have to reapply her eyeliner throughout the day either. This is, hands down, your best formula yet, and I sincerely hope you never change it! Fun little story: I was actually introduced to Make Up For Ever eye pencils decades ago when I was flipping through a fashion magazine and read that Denise Richards was a fan. I decided to give them a try, and I’ve been a fan ever since.

Horrible update! I still have the previous version of this eyeliner and it was so much better. The new one is shorter (less product), does not twist up (impossible to use), and the packaging feels hollow (cheap). I went to the store today because I wanted one that works and was informed I would have to sharpen it on my own and I would have to purchase a separate sharpener. Why does the end of the pencil twist if it is not going to lengthen and sharpen the product? No one wants anything this difficult to use. I am rushing to get ready in the mornings or touch up later in the day and every second counts. I do not have time for this and will not buy again.