The Harper Mule

Fits perfectly true to size, looks stunning, easy to go with any outfit. I love this pair of shoes. The reason why I give this a 3 star is because they are not comfy after walking in these for a while. My feet hurt and couldn’t walk anymore. Only good for some office days or some activity without walking around and standing for a long time.

I would give 5 star, except that I think its slightly cheap, after a wear, I had to return a pair when the inside slip, keeps coming off when you take the shoe off. I love it so much that I bought another pair to try and see if it was just that one pair. I have this shoe in Off-white and black. The black has worked so far with no issues

So many shoes with this quality of construction are too heavy. This shoe has a good solid construction but does not weigh me down. Beautiful shape; quality workmanship and great fit. What more could a girl ask?

Soooo comfortable! I have pretty wide but bony feet so can’t wear narrow shoes for long. But I was able to with these babes!!! Highly recommended

Couldn't be more pleased with these mules! The height is super comfortable to walk in, and they actually work wonderfully for women with wider feet like mine. I do think that they run just slightly large length-wise, and there's extra room around the top of my foot. I feel like color in real life is also less vibrant than pictured here. Nonetheless, I think the color is very pretty in real life and has an elongating effect against my medium skin tone. Overall, super pleased with this purchase and would highly recommend!

The look is exactly what I wanted and the fit was fine. Unfortunately, the construction was so poor that both soles cracked completely across the entire width of the shoe after I wore them 3 times. So disappointing - now I’m on the look out for a similar style that won’t fall apart after 3 wears.

These are by far not the most expensive shoes I’ve purchased and I’ve never felt the need to write a bad review, but I didn’t even unwrap the second shoe! The leather looks cheap. The sizing is so off I don’t know where to begin. I am a TRUE 6.5 these were so short and ill fitting, way too wide around the top of the shoe. Poorly designed. Returned immediately. Very disappointing. Can’t even describe the fit. Too short too wide at top…

Casual, dressy, easy, comfortable. My go to shoes!

I tried to go as long as possible with these shoes because they were so cute but the pain was unbearable. These shoes gave me multiple blisters and just after the second time wearing them the inside sole lining came out. Love Madewell items but this one was a flop....wish they were more comfortable because I really loved the look.

I've had these for over three months now. I like the look, they fit TTS, and the sole and leather upper seem to be holding up well. But the lining immediately started coming up around my toes the first or second time I wore them, and it's only gotten worse. I've never had that happen in a shoe before. When I take the shoes off the lining comes out too, peeling up and out of the mule. I have to scrunch the linings down each time I put the shoes on, and they come up between my toes as I walk. It's SO annoying. I'll have to super-glue the linings or take them to a cobbler or something. I'm sad, because I like Madewell's designs, but this isn't, well, well-made.

These shoes are so uncomfortable. I got blisters on both pinky toes after wearing for a few hours. They are also poor quality. The lining started coming out in the left shoe after wearing for one day. Way overpriced for how terribly they are made.

I had the soles separated from the base of the shoe after about 6 months.