Skip navigation

Get $40 off your next purchase, plus an extra 5% off at Nordstrom Rack. Terms apply. Apply Now

Main content
  1. Home
(51)51

MAC Eye Pencil

MAC Cosmetics

Sold Out

SOLD OUT

This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.

Details & care

M·A·C Eye Pencil is formulated to provide rich, consistent color. It's comfortable to apply and sharpens to a fine point for precise application. Use it to create a sharp line or a softer, smoky effect.

How to use: Apply directly to lid.

  • Dermatologist tested; ophthalmologist tested
  • Nonacnegenic
  • Item #10822U
  • Core Product ID 333333V3PF

Shipping & returns

Free shipping. Free returns. All the time. Purchases made online can also be returned or exchanged at any Nordstrom store, free of charge. Read more about our shipping & returns policies.

Gift options

Choose your gift options at Checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

MAC Cosmetics

All Ages, All Races, All Genders. Every individual has the desire and ability to define beauty for themselves—with a little help from MAC. With easy-to-use products and trends directly from MAC artists behind the runways and on-set around the world, it's everything a makeup addict can't live without. After March 31, 2023, MAC will discontinue the free product incentive (though you can continue to bring in your empties!) as part of the program's evolution to have greater action and impact for change. More news on this soon!

Reviews

(51)514.1 out of 5
Write a Review

Most helpful positive review

Feb 15, 2010

Coffee is the best for Brunette eyebrows!

I've gone through every MAC eyebrow pencil color and every brands eyebrow promises. I don't have thick eyebrows and I need to help them with shadows and liners. I found this pencil and I'll never turn back. Or course you could use it on your eyes to line them but if you're looking for an eyebrow pencil and you're brunette, try Coffee. You know how they're always too red or light or ash or even orange. This is the one. Just don't bother telling the sales woman your secret otherwise you'll waste an extra few minutes of your time listening to her tell you about their eyebrow products. This one works great, goes on easily and stays put. Use Brun MAC eyeshadow first and then touch up unfilled areas with this pencil. You'll love me.
HonestOne
7found this helpful

Most helpful critical review

Mar 24, 2024

Disappointed

I haven't bought from MAC before. Assistant kind and chose eye pencil in the colour 'coffee' for me. (She didn't mention it wasn't waterproof or tell me they have a waterproof eye pencil which I would have preferred). This particularly eye pencil fades quickly and smudges. No use to me as I am constantly checking it hasn't smudged onto my under eye. Very disappointed and will return item.
Pippa

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars55%
4 stars24%
3 stars6%
2 stars6%
1 star10%
Feb 15, 2010

Coffee is the best for Brunette eyebrows!

I've gone through every MAC eyebrow pencil color and every brands eyebrow promises. I don't have thick eyebrows and I need to help them with shadows and liners. I found this pencil and I'll never turn back. Or course you could use it on your eyes to line them but if you're looking for an eyebrow pencil and you're brunette, try Coffee. You know how they're always too red or light or ash or even orange. This is the one. Just don't bother telling the sales woman your secret otherwise you'll waste an extra few minutes of your time listening to her tell you about their eyebrow products. This one works great, goes on easily and stays put. Use Brun MAC eyeshadow first and then touch up unfilled areas with this pencil. You'll love me.
HonestOne
7found this helpful
Aug 15, 2014

Perfect

I bought this to replace my Mac PowerPoint pencil, which is long-lasting and great for the eye lid, but gets everywhere on the water line. This pencil pretty much works in the same way and has the staying power but is also great for the water line. It makes a smooth line on the eyelid and it sharpens to a fine point. The only con is that if you are prone to rubbing or touching ur eyes, it will smudge. So I guess it doesn't really set. I'm not sure if any eye liner does.
Kato2010
3found this helpful
Jan 2, 2013

Forgot how much I love MAC eye pencils!

I always used to use MAC eyeliners, pencils, etc - but somehow started using some other lines brands, Clinique, Chanel... Laura Mercier. Not the same as MAC, just got a brown pencil, it's the best. I'm in my 50's now and the MAC pencils don't pull your eyelid going on, so smooth and rich and they last! Going to buy more. Nordstrom delivered it free in like 1 day, too!
DIVAMXG
3found this helpful
July 31, 2014

Coffee to eyes

It's very soft so it doesn't bother your eyes, color is great. I like natural looking make up, and this eye liner is perfect for that. Didn't get a chance to sharpen yet, so don't know how easy to sharpen this with a very soft pencil. Like it so far!
ndholic
2found this helpful
Jan 7, 2012

Color

I really like the pencil, the color was way to black for me. Coffee is a very Black Coffee. I plan on using it still even tho it's a little too dark for me.
cowgirl2012
2found this helpful
Aug 9, 2016

Great Color

This eye pencil is a wonderful alternative to black, when you want something a little lighter, but still dramatic. It is a very deep, rich brown. I have blue eyes, and love the way it looks on me. The texture is perfect, it glides on smoothly. I have very sensitive skin and eyes and noticed some irritation in my eyes when I wore a heavier than usual amount of eyeliner.
Katrina96
1found this helpful