Holcomb Waterproof Plain Toe Derby

These shoes are comfortable and really nice to wear for church. They feel well and look very good. Encourage others to get it.

Amazing fit! True to size, looks great with every pant color.

I tried two types of shoes and in both I found it impossible to feel as comfortable as with those that have a heel rest support and I would like them to continue manufacturing them.

A nice shoe. Good comfort and quality materials. A tad heavy .

I couldn’t be more impressed with my Johnston & Murphy dress shoes. From the moment I unboxed them, the craftsmanship was obvious—premium leather, elegant stitching, and a sleek silhouette that instantly elevates any outfit. What truly stands out is the comfort. These shoes required almost no break-in period. The footbed offers excellent support, and even after a full day on my feet, they still feel great. Whether I'm at the office, a formal event, or just dressing sharp for a night out, these shoes deliver on both style and practicality. I’ve received several compliments, and people are always surprised when I say they’re not custom-made—because that’s how they feel. Johnston & Murphy has nailed the balance of timeless design and modern comfort. Highly recommended for anyone who values quality and wants a shoe that looks as good as it performs.

I recently purchased a pair of waterproof Johnston & Murphy shoes for my husband, and we are both extremely impressed with the quality and style. The craftsmanship is top-notch — from the stitching to the leather finish, everything looks and feels premium. He mentioned how comfortable they were right out of the box, with no break-in period needed, which is rare for dress shoes. They’re versatile enough to wear with both professional and more casual outfits, and he’s already received several compliments. These shoes strike a great balance between timeless design and everyday wearability. I highly recommend Johnston & Murphy for anyone looking for durable, stylish footwear that doesn’t compromise on comfort.