





SOLD OUT
This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.
Details & care
Dip-dyed calfskin leather enriches a timeless plain-toe derby constructed with soft insole cushioning and a durable Goodyear-stitched welt.
- Lace-up style
- Removable, cushioned insole with arch support
- Leather upper and lining/leather and rubber sole
- Imported
- Item #10319662
Size info
- True to size.
Gift options
Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.
Delivery
- Email gift message (free)
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Most helpful positive review
Nov 4, 2025
Exceptional Comfort and Timeless Craftsmanship
I own several pairs from the Crafted Collection, and while they’re always stylish and well-made, I’ve often found them a bit less flexible than I’d prefer. That said, the design, craftsmanship, and overall quality keep me coming back. This Dudley Plain Toe stands out as one of the most comfortable pairs in the entire collection that I owe. The leather is beautifully dyed, and the attention to detail is exactly what I’ve come to expect from the Crafted Collection. A perfect blend of comfort, style, and premium quality.
Mark
Verified purchase
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Most helpful critical review
Sept 2, 2024
Sizes are not accurate
I just bought a pair of shoes and again they are much smaller than they should be.
Michael
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
5 stars
73%
4 stars
17%
3 stars
3%
2 stars
3%
1 star
3%
Sort by Most Helpful
Mark
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Verified purchase
Nov 4, 2025
Exceptional Comfort and Timeless Craftsmanship
I own several pairs from the Crafted Collection, and while they’re always stylish and well-made, I’ve often found them a bit less flexible than I’d prefer. That said, the design, craftsmanship, and overall quality keep me coming back. This Dudley Plain Toe stands out as one of the most comfortable pairs in the entire collection that I owe. The leather is beautifully dyed, and the attention to detail is exactly what I’ve come to expect from the Crafted Collection. A perfect blend of comfort, style, and premium quality.
Randy
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Apr 29, 2025
Great looking shoe but a bit narrow
The color and quality of the shoe is top notch. I prefer the leather soles and sadly, over the years, J&M seems to veer from this style for the more casual rubber soles.
This pair is narrower than the others styles I have. Hopefully, they will give a bit with time. However, it's a great looking shoe and an uncommon color. It can be dressed up or down.
Dave
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Mar 26, 2025
Great Looking Shoe
Beautiful shoe true to its online look. Length is consistent with other J&M shoes, however, the width is a bit tight. Hopefully it loosens up over time.
Jeffrey
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Mar 13, 2025
Blue leather shoes
The fit great and got many compliments recently when worn at a formal wedding!
Charles
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Feb 7, 2025
Style & Craftsmanship
An exquisite pair of dress shoes for any Occassion. Superb craftsmanship and style.
Scott
Reposted from Johnston & Murphy
Jan 13, 2025
Navy Dudley
Good quality, good fit, a little hard to break it.