Most Wanted Short Sleeve Cotton Blend Cardigan

So sad!!! I thought this would be a winner , but the sleeves are as tight as rubber bands (and I don't have large arms?) super uncomfortable and just have to return, bummed!! *I'm 5'7" and 145 lbs*

Loved this so much bought in another color..and probably will get another , lol. Typically stay clear of button down shirts because of having a larger chest however it did not gap and looked very classy on. Wore with leggings and with jeans and looks great with both. For reference got size Medium and I have a shorter torso , Large chest. Not tight on my arms and comfortable material.

I got this top in my regular size and it was way too small! This is not one of your typical oversize Free People garments. Fabric is nice and it's well constructed, but it is close-fitting without a lot of give. Might work for a smaller chested woman. I gave it to my size small daughter and it fits her and is not super tight.

This is the second of this top I’d bought, after returning the first due to the buttonholes gaping. I assumed it was an issue with that one top, but this one is gaping badly as well. I usually wear an xs and don’t have a large chest so there’s no reason for the buttons to keep popping. The buttonholes themselves aren’t reinforced with thread so they slowly stretch as you wear it. Bad design .

This shirt is super cute, but unfortunately it’s completely unwearable. I am petite and do not have a large chest but the buttons constantly pop open, which made for a very embarrassing experience when I wore it out for a day trip. I had to buy safety pins to keep it together

The rust color is not the same as advertised however the fit is flattering. I went for a small but a medium might do better for a 32 DDD bust.

Cannot say anything negative about this top. At 5-6, 135, 36C I liked the size XL since this has nice, natural cotton, which we all know shrinks. I like a tad of roomie-ness, not ultra tight so got bigger size. It worked. It is not baggy but not ultra skin hugging when I sized up. So when it shrinks which h is normal, it will still fit. Love the cotton with some stretch. This top’s buttons are just fine. Ignore the other reviews. Just put the top in over the head and stop playing with buttons. But regardless I have never had a problem with these buttons on the three colors I purchased. I like how this top can be a u-neck, v-neck or just button to top depending on the even it can be modest at neckline and bottom or tad sexy at neck and bottom with unbuttoned. You get to decide. One can also wear a camo under it to open up too like a short sleeve cardigan. The material is NOT cheap, thin cotton. It has a thicker feel which is great So it is NOT see-thru. The price is GREAT. East with Jean or cotton shorts, linen or flowery skirts, on top of short sleeve dresses to hide arms or shoulders, or again again as a cardigan over a camisole. I just wear it buttoned up with few unbuttoned at top and a jean skirt, white modern shorts, natural color shorts and a crossbody or top handle handbag with a purse scarf and wedge sandals. Looks so modern, feminine, hip depending on how you wear it. Love the colors.

This top run a size small and sleeves are very tight and not coordinated for size. If you have a chest and want cropped this is for you. The material was ok, a bit thick, the ivory was darker and more yellow than shows online. Disappointed, looks nicer online than in person.

Love this shirt. I did end up sewing it closed to fix the gaping, but that’s a typical problem for me with buttoned tops. I also had to size up for the arm holes, but it is my favorite work top at the moment. It does pill a bit after being washed a few times.

I purchased two of these tops, both XS- one in black and one in ivory. Great quality in terms of thickness, the ivory one is not see through, however even though it fits properly, there are gaps between buttons and you can see my bra. Unfortunately I have to return because of that. That was not the issue with the black top, but the black top did have a bunch of lose strings, which I will manicure and keep. So they both have pro/con in different ways, which is odd. The ivory is also much more yellow than I thought it would be.

This top is super cute on, but it’s super painful. The arm holes are super tight. Other than that, it looks cute, but it’s too painful to wear especially for someone who is picky about comfort like me. I normally wear a small and if I went up in size it would be too big

People will tell you that the dupes for this Free People top are just as good. They are not. They are not nearly as soft. This tee is so soft, and comfortable, and the dupes I have tried have been very stiff and uncomfortable. It does run short, so maybe size up. I wish they made one in a slightly less cropped style also.