Eyeliner Pencil Refill

Ok when I bought this, I thought it is an option to have the holder -- so this cartridge is usable on its own but I was wrong. The description written here for this product is not sufficient, they should have mentioned that in order to use this pen you HAVE to buy the holder because without it is is useless. As you will see from the pictures attached, this cartridge has a plastic rollers at the bottom, so it needs to be rolled in order for the inside pen to move up and then you can use it. Also to mention this is one TINY pen! Quality wise of the pencil is just standard -- so you can find other brands with better offerings with above this quality.

A blog I trust wrote a feature on this eyeliner. The review was raving, and I was in the market for a new eyeliner because so many I've tried are hard, smudge too easily, or fade. I'm glad I made the purchase, because this eyeliner has none of those problems. The line it gives is soft, dark, smooth, and just absolutely lovely. It lasts almost all day, and doesn't irritate my eyes (which are sensitive). It gets five stars from me, because I can't think of a way in which they could improve the product. The only disappointment with this product is the product image online. It shows the full cartridge and holder, which is not what you get. These two items are sold separately. Thankfully, because of free shipping, it doesn't cost me any extra to order it separately.

I wish I had read some of the lower rated reviews before buying this liner. I would not have purchased it. I agree it is hard to use. It seems dry and doesn't go on smoothly. I like that it has a rubber brush at the end to smooth the liner, but it doesn't work if the pencil doesn't draw a very good line. I wouldn't buy it again.