This is a good option for Petites who want the maxi cardigan look but have difficulty pulling it off. I am 5'2" and the XXS comes to the base of my knee. I did try the PP and found it to be no different in size. I love the rustic linen material, and the pewter color blends so nicely with all the EF neutrals. The material is soft and comfortable but not really warm enough to be a winter layer. The sweater looks very different depending on whether it is buttoned or not, so it is sort of like getting 2 pieces in one (a knit dress and a long cardigan). The material does stretch out a bit, so there is no need to size up.

The sweater is fun and fashionable. Looks great with jeans or over simple dress. And the color is great!

I LOVE linen clothing and was surprised to see a sweater in a light weight linen. Love this sweater.

I was looking for a lightweight long cardigan that was a bit different, and this one is lovely--beautiful texture and color. I'm 5'8" so don't know if it would work well if you are shorter. As always with EF tops, I ordered down one size (from L to M), and the fit is fine.

Didn't do anything for me. Good quality, but just didn't find it flattering.