Chubby Stick™ Eye Shadow Tint For Eyes

I have recently tried Amber and Fudge in the new Clinique chubby sticks. I also bought them for my 23 yr old daughter for her birthday and she loves them too. The Amber is my favorite that I use as my base shadow. I stopped using powder eye shadows over three years ago when I tried Benefit cream eye shadows because they had at the time the best selection of colors and they lasted until you took them off. I started to hate powder eye shadows because they immediately end up on your cheeks or eyelashes when you use most brushes or they fade away or just end up in your eyes or contact lenses. I have been disappointed with the colors that other companies make in cream eye shadows though. They were either to light or to dark for my skin color. Im a light to medium olive skin person and most beiges turn white on me, and I have dark circles so dark shadows don't look that good either. I have been looking for a color like Amber as a base because its a rose gold and it doesn't lighten on me, stays true to the color and then sometimes I put the fudge on the outer edge of my eyelid and blend. I love these and hope Clinique will never discontinue especially the Amber so I bought two of those at once.

I was disappointed with the "Chubby Stick", and Nordstrom, for a number of different reasons, the first being a shipping issue. Nordstrom sent one eyeshadow stick, along with one other very small item that I had ordered, in a box that measured 13" x 11" #MUCH TOO LARGE!#, and which contained NO packing material to cushion the items in order to prevent damage. The two items were loosely wrapped in what can only be described as a type of butcher paper and, therefore, the eyeshadow stick was damaged in shipping #the actual eyeshadow within the stick was broken#. When I contacted Nordstrom to request a replacement, I was told that the shipping department attempts to be environmentally-friendly, which I commend, but they also need to be customer-friendly, and ensure that the orders will arrive in perfect condition! In this instance, a small, padded, recyclable shipping envelope and/or "air pillows" could have been used, rather than an oversized box lined merely with butcher paper and NO other cushioning material! Secondly, I had posted a question, prior to ordering the "Chubby Stick", to inquire as to whether or not the eyeshadow has any type of glitter, sparkle, or metallic shine to it. I am over 50, and I do not want to look as if I borrowed eyeshadow from a 12-year-old! I received a reply from Nordstrom, assuring me that it has a soft shimmer with a velvet finish, which is not overbearing, and the shimmer does not show up as sparkle on the eyes! Well, I guess that that is open to interpretation because, in my opinion, there is quite A LOT of sparkle/shimmer/glitter; TOO MUCH for my taste! Plus, the stick itself is SO "chubby" that, when applied to the eye, it ends up spreading shadow onto the surrounding area of the eyelid and up toward the eyebrows! On a positive note, I do like the color of the "Chubby Stick" that I ordered, the texture of the eyeshadow itself, and the fact that it comes in stick form. I would just prefer that it be not-so-chubby #put it on a 'diet' and slim it down!#, and NOT have any sparkle whatsoever; a soft, subtle matte finish would be much better, especially for those of us who prefer to look age-appropriate! As a result, I rated this product as "Fair" since, in my opinion, it needs some tweaking before it would ever recieve a 5-star rating!

I had been hearing and reading about the chubby sticks for a while and finally bit the bullet to try them. I ended up buying three different colors for the eyes - I LOVE them! I am a busy mom of two toddlers and I must admit that when it comes to makeup, I just don't find myself wearing it as much as I used to for one reason or another (mostly laziness). These chubby sticks are seriously AMAZING - I am obsessed with the fact that it is so easy and quick to apply. No brush, no powder mess, nothing. They are also super build-able and versatile - you can change your look with a few extra swipes. So fun, so easy. Another random note, I ended up purchasing the Lots o' Latte, Bountiful Beige and and Lavish Lilac. The beige is super natural looking and I mostly use it for highlighting. Surprisingly, the Lavish Lilac is my favorite - almost a silvery/gray with a tiny hint of purple. I would highly recommend trying these, I love them and they last all day for me!

I didn't own much Clinique makeup and Chubby Stick tint for eyes is my most recent purchase from the brand. I was intrigued after reading a glowing review from a beauty blogger and got my hands on three of them - Ample Amber, Fuller Fudge, and Whopping Willow. The colors are very saturated and creamy, shiny but not glittery. I'm instantly blown away by the rich colors when I swatched them on my hand, and got even happier when I directly applied them on my lids. They give you what's promised - glides on creamy colors, with long wearing and smooth finish. I like the stick for eyes as they are portable, smudge able and easy to use. Love them even better when it comes with the swivel mechanism so I don't have to worry about getting a sharpener. All in all I'm very happy with the purchase on these stick tints for eyes, and will highly recommend to others.

I love the chubby sticks for lips, and was expecting this to be a similarly creamy consistency. Instead it's hard as a rock, and pulls the skin when applying. Very disappointed.

Love this product by Clinique! It is so easy to apply and use and I have the pearl white and the Khiki colors plus I have the rose colored stick I think that is for lips. Anyway, I am 78 years old and love to have eye make-up that looks good. This is easy to use and when I brush a little powdered light green eye makeup over the bottom part I think it looks great, I am very satisfied and hope they keep making it! The associate I worked with was so helpful too, she found just what I was looking for! Thanks Nordstrom!

I got the chubby sticks in 'Massive Midnight' and 'Fuller Fudge'. I thought the 'Massive Midnight' (which is a dark navy color) would help me to create a more smoky eye look for my gray/silver shadows since they didn't have 'Curvaceous Coal' in stock at the time. But it ended up looking like a big mess and was difficult to apply smoothly and blend. The 'Fuller Fudge' however, is a sheerer neutral brown color and was easy to apply and blend. I use it as a base before applying powder eyeshadow and find it makes the eyeshadow stick around longer and without too much creasing. On its own however, since I have oily skin, it creased and smudged. It would probably depend on your skin type and the look you are going for, if these chubby sticks would work for you or not. I would still recommend it because with the right color, it is easy to apply and small and portable. I also liked that you just twist the stick up and it doesn't need sharpening. I would recommend going to the store and trying the colors on before purchasing.

I normally buy more expensive lines like Chanel and Dior, but decided to give this one a try. I'm also not a fan of wet shadows because they tend to cake. This one goes on dry and smooth, and doesn't collect in creases. My eyes have been watering more lately from allergies, but this shadow stays put. Really happy with this purchase.

It goes on smooth, does not leave creases. Soft and sensitive.

Goes on easily, unlike pencils; non-irritating, unlike powder which can float into your eye. I bought the coal color, which is a bit on the dark side but can be lightened by smudging. I would give it more stars if I could, an excellent product. I will be buying other colors and a backup of the coal. Hope this will be available for a while.

I like the idea of the chubby stick and the easy application. But it wasn't for me. I found the colors to be too shimmery, and I couldn't;t seem to find a color that was a great match for me. I also felt that they were a little drying on my eyelids. I am giving 3 stars because I didn't dislike these entirely but they are not something I would probably buy again in the future.

I bought 4 colors to try - biege, amber, willow, fudge. I'm a low maintenance person, so I don't spend ton of time putting on makeup. Thought these chubby shadow sticks were a good idea to try. I really wanted to love them but unfortunately, I do not. Formula is not up to par for me. I had to swipe over my eye lids several times and seems a bit drying as well. I expected them to be creamier and more pigmented. Also, biege color hardly shows up on my light-med skintone. Willow when blended does not look green. Amber is too peachy rather than bronzy/golden tone. Fudge is the best color of the 4 I got. For the price I paid, I expected more from the product. Oh well, back they go.