Floral Embroidery Western Boot (Women)

Ordered these boots, and the very similar "Flower Embroidery" Western Boot. Each pair seems to be built on the same platform, remarkably similar, just differences in the details and flowers. Both are beautiful; I prefer the Flower Embroidery style over this one, the Floral Embroidery. See photos for side-by-side comparison; judge for yourself. Pros: Real leather, smells divine. Leather soles & a shorter heel - perfect for line dancing. Even with the pointy toe, comfortable. First pointy pair for which this has been the case. Beautiful boots! Sizing: Am struggling with what size cowboy boots to order, as each pair / brand I try seems slightly different. Ordered these in an 8.5 and a 9. 9 is a little too large, with a bit too much heel slip - would likely be doable with a thick sock or different insole. From online research, this means they are likely a little too big, especially as real leather boots are supposed to mold to your feet over time and develop "give". Size 9 was the slightest big clunky. Cons: Tried the 8.5 on the right foot. WAY too small, tight & uncomfortable. For fun, I tried on the left foot's 8.5. It fits perfectly. There is a very big difference in the left and the right, almost like the right foot is actually a size 8. Never have I experienced such a big difference between a right and left foot, and I have tried on a TON of shoes and boots over the years. Sadly returning both pair. Hopeful a fresh order with 8.5 will be perfect! My narrow foot normally wears a size 9, but in this style, the 8.5 looks like it will do the trick.