Long Sleeve Crewneck T-Shirt

Sadly, these Caslon tops of which I must have 20 in my closet are not the same and I returned them. This year the fabric is thinner and it is just not as solid feeling as the previous ones. I have loved them because of how they fit and how they keep their shape and how long they wear. I think a message to the reps of this brand should be if you are trying to keep the price down by using a less expensive fabric -- don't -- at least not for me. I would rather pay another dollar or two and keep the quality.

This is a perfectly fine shirt. It's just a simple long-sleeve tee. It gets the job done. The material is soft and thin. I would wear it alone on a warm day. It would be fine for a business casual office with a scarf or a second layer. The blue grey color is not see-through. The neck is a little wider than I expected - you can see sports bra straps, but normal bra straps probably would not show. 5'4", 128lbs, size Small fits as expected.

I am 5'2'' 100 lbs. and bought the Petite XS. I was excited to find Petite sizes, as shopping can be frustrating when you're swimming in everything you try on. Well-- the Petite ended up not being a great idea for this. The sleeves were an awkwardly short length, and they only looked good if I pushed them up. A regular XS probably would have fit my arm length better, but I decided to return the shirt rather than exchange due to the fact that it is thin and would require a tank top underneath. I was hoping for this shirt to be my base layer and not need another layer under it.

I returned this top. I got the medium (I'm usually a size 6 but busty so I normally size up). It felt too tight and it was thinner than I expected. The burgundy color is beautiful and I like the style but overall it felt cheap, as if it would get holes quickly. It did not hang on me the way it does in the model photo. I am looking for that style but in a more substantial knit and relaxed fit.