SOLD OUT
This item is no longer available. Browse our recommendations for something similar.
Details & care
This super creamy and smooth putty will feel and look like butter in your child's hands. Better Butter Thinking Putty® will brighten their day with its gorgeous yellow hue and mashable texture.
- Warning: Choking hazard. Small parts. Not for children under 3 years
- 0.42 oz.
- Silicone
- Made in the USA
- Item #11020731
Gift options
Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.
Delivery
- Email gift message (free)
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Most helpful positive review
Mar 24, 2026
It is amazing
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I bought this the other day and it actually feels like butter
Mia23
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Most helpful critical review
Mar 6, 2026
Not satisfied. :(
I only had for like two weeks and already its changed to like a gray, its reallllllly sticky, and smells...weird. It never really smelled like butter even when I got it. BOOOO.
bob27
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
5 stars
89%
4 stars
6%
3 stars
3%
2 stars
3%
1 star
0%
Pros:
Cons:
Current reviews don’t mention any.Sort by Most Helpful
Mia23
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Mar 24, 2026
It is amazing
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I bought this the other day and it actually feels like butter
bob27
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Mar 6, 2026
Not satisfied. :(
I only had for like two weeks and already its changed to like a gray, its reallllllly sticky, and smells...weird. It never really smelled like butter even when I got it. BOOOO.
Puttyguy
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Mar 5, 2026
10/10 product!
Crazy Aaron's took all the good things about butter, like the scent, color, and smoothness, and put it in a putty! (Except for the taste :)) Its not oily, but is really smooth. It also has a nice pleasant scent like butter.
Zahra
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Feb 2, 2026
Amazing
I bought this a month ago and I’m so happy I did because it is just the best
Johnny
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Feb 1, 2026
Best putty ever!!!
This better butter putty is freaking amazing!!! I bring it to work and I literally play with it most of the day! It is so soft and smooth and I love how the air bubbles make it pop! Only thing I don’t like is that it does collect hair and stuff and if you get any kind of chemical in it, it instantly gets super sticky so I had to get another one which is fine because I love it!! Definitely recommend if you want something to figet with and not get sticky crap all over your hands!
ilovethinkingputty
Reposted from Crazy Aaron's
Jan 21, 2026
Softest-Bestest Putty!
AMAZING!!! I have been trying to find slime which wont dry out. But this putty is practically like butter slime! I would recommend getting it before it goes out of stock.