Judgement Bootie (Women)

Beautiful and comfortable. Many other websites reviews stated order a size up, runs small. I am a size 11 so that isn’t possible but I feel in my case these shoes fit true to size perfectly. That being said, I can fit into a size 10 if the boot is on the wider side. I have neither wide nor narrow feet. They are medium and when I took the shoes out of the box I was concerned because they looked narrow but they fit just right and I don’t like tight shoes. The leather is beautiful and if they hold up for a long time then I don’t mind paying the price.

I bought all three colors in size 7 and I stuck with the oxidized and returned the others. I wear 6.5 but sized up after reading many reviews. The black rustic is greyer in person, but I decided against this color simply because it felt tighter/stiffer than the tan or oxidized. The tan was brighter/lighter than I preferred, and the fit was ok. One shoe felt tighter than the other even after adjusting the laces. I’m not sure why the pairs I ordered had so much inconsistency with sizing. Fortunately, I liked the oxidized the most and their fit was the best. I might’ve kept the black had it fit better. For the price of these boots, I wish the quality was better and fit more consistent. There are some places between the sole and the leather upper where the glue looks uneven. Additionally, the red bottom sole at the toe is already cracking after less than a month of use.

These are beautifully made booties with a fun design that is of the moment but has also stood the test of time; they are full of character and seem like they'll hold up well to wear. I look forward to many years of pairing them with my favorite work and play clothes. They do seem a little bit small, being somewhat tight when worn with normal cotton socks, but with thinner cotton or dress socks they fit perfectly. If you're in between sizes I'd definitely prefer at least a half size up, if possible. I normally wear a 10.5-11 in women's shoes, and my feet are on the narrow side of medium width.

These boots were very well made, exactly as pictured and looked super cute on but they were pretty small for an 8 and so stiff in the heel they would give blisters for sure. Because the leather is so thick and nice I’m sure they would eventually break in but I didn’t want to deal with that so I returned them. I think an 8.5 would have been more comfortable for me even though I’m usually a 7.5-8 but maybe they would work if the leather stretches.