Randolph 2.0 Loafer

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Randolph 2.0 Penny Loafer is beautifully crafted with understated elegance. The leather is sturdy yet supple and required no break in. It fit like a glove right out of the box. It is a versatile shoe that can be dressed up or down and can be worn with slacks, chinos, or jeans. If you are looking for a foundational classic shoe that will never go out of style, this is the one.

Sizing is an issue, apparently depending on the sole type (reflection of precise manufacturing location) as those with "Bench Welt" or Rendenbach tended to be shorter/narrower in the front and wider in the heel, while "Leather" Non-"bench welt" soles were longer/wider front, narrower heel. I normally wear 9D/E in most shoes, including many AEs, but for loafers including these I need to size up to 9.5, with the normal non-bench-welt soles (the bench welt--and I ordered several"). Style is the other element. I'm evidently more of a bit-loafer chap than I am a penny chap. Personal preference, I'm just less a fan of the penny when worn than the bit.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] High quality loafers. Traditional and elegant. Break in is a bit longer than other AE loafer models (like the Italian drivers), impacting comfort. Build is great. Consider a half size smaller — recommend trying them on. My heels slipped out in my typical AE Oxford size.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Really like these shoes but there are some major quality control issues. The stitches on the bottom of the sole fall outside of the grooved "track" and I am concerned that there will be premature wear. There also is a deep separation / gap in one of the heels. I feel that this is unacceptable at this price point. I likely will be returning and hope they can provide a new pair without these defects.