Ashton Venetian Loafer (Men)

Bought this shoe for my teenaged son. We bought his usual 11.5, only to return them because they were far too large. We sized down to a 10.5. The replacement pair was also too large, in fact, we thought they were the same size as the first pair. This is a nice loafer and my son likes how they look, but the sizing has left us so perplexed, we're giving up and trying a different shoe entirely. Too bad. Maybe you'll have better luck buying in store.