59C Penny Loafer

I was skeptical to order this loafer because I am picku as heck. I have been looking for a simple style black loafer and this shoe is gorgeous. So comfortable right out the box. Love a high end shoe and this was reasonably priced. Ordered half size up.

Have worn a pair of Todd’s for ten+ years, still look and feel great. So, when this penny loafer style arrived, I snapped up two pairs. Worn one and love it.

This shoe was stiff and not worth the price to me. So it went back.

I really wanted to live this pair but had to return them. Reasons 1-the leather is absolutely too stiff. It’ll take a long painful wears to break in. 2- it runs too narrow. 3- it’s more like patent, too shiny to me.

These are the first penny loafers I’ve owned and I love them. The were immediately comfy when trying them on in store in a thin sock. At home I tried a little thicker still fit great and even bare foot still comfy. I did size up a whole size as I usually wear a 10 but went straight for a whole size up being they’re considered designer and I’ll wear socks too. Worn them once out in the world and they’re still comfy don the city streets. No “break in”time needed. Ready to wear right out the box! A treat for your feet!

I love these shoes. The patent ads some panache' to an otherwise traditional penny loafer. I normally wear a 39 or 39.5. The 39.5 was a better fit. The 39 was too narrow for me. The rubber sole adds to the comfort.