Katie Mary Jane Pump (Women)

I’m still giving them 5 stars because they are adorable and I assume they would be comfortable if they fit. Sadly, even though I ordered my size, these shoes are so tight that there is no way that can wear them. Seems like I’m squeezing into a 6.5. I’m an 8. So definitely order up. Not just for in between sizes like they said. I am a solid 8. 8.5 is too big. I can fit into a 7.5 only if I have to.

These are beautifully crafted and classic Mary Jane shoes-definitely worth every penny. I gave them 4 stars because they run small and I can only find them online-I have to return the size 8’s that I bought, and because they don’t run in 1/2 sizes, I will have to order size 9’s and hope they aren’t too big. The 8’s were pretty darn small, and that is my normal shoe size. So if ordering these shoes, go up a size up for sure!

These are cute basic Mary Jane but I found them too uncomfortable to justify the price. The toe box is a little shallow for me and the edges of the leather are super sharp, it would definitely be digging in if I wore them for very long. Honestly remind me of the cheap patent leather ones I wore as a little kid. Also the strap placement is a little too high for me.

If considering this shoe keep in mind European sizing -- I started with a 39, then returned it for a 40. (I am U.S. size 9.) The 39 was tight the 40 could have worked but the strap keeper on the right shoe did not allow me to push the strap thru. Even when it was not on my foot I could not get it thru -- whether it was the stitching on the strap end or the keeper itself(?) Nice shoe but gave up and returned it.