Skip navigation

Get $40 off your next purchase, plus an extra 5% off at Nordstrom Rack. Terms apply. Apply Now

Main content
  1. Home
  2. Men
  3. Shoes
  4. Athletic & Sneakers
McGuffey 2 175th Plain Toe Derby video
(13)13

McGuffey 2 175th Plain Toe Derby

Johnston & Murphy

Men

Current Price $129.00 to $175.00
Up to 26% off select items.
Previous Price $175.00
Color
Color: Tan Oiled American Full Grain
Sale
Size
M
1 person viewing now
Free returns anytime
Sold by Nordstrom
Select fulfillment method
Get $40 off your next purchase! When you're approved for a new Nordstrom credit card. Plus, an extra 5% off at Nordstrom Rack. Terms apply. Apply Now

Details & care

A smooth leather upper streamlines a smart derby with memory-foam cushioning and a high rebound, XC Foam® midsole for lasting comfort.

  • Lace-up style
  • Leather upper/leather and textile lining/rubber sole
  • Imported
  • Item #10763313
  • Core Product ID 333333T8G5

Shipping & returns

Free shipping. Free returns. All the time. Purchases made online can also be returned or exchanged at any Nordstrom store, free of charge. Read more about our shipping & returns policies.

Gift options

Choose your gift options at checkout. Some items may not be eligible for all gift options.

Free Pickup

  • Printed gift message (free)
  • Nordstrom gift box (free)
  • Fabric gift bag ($5)

Delivery

  • Email gift message (free)
  • Printed gift message (free)
  • Fabric gift bag ($5)
Need help finding the perfect gift? We've got you covered.
Shop Gifts

Johnston & Murphy

Not many brands can boast what Johnston & Murphy can. Since 1850, the company has "outfitted legends, leaders and independent souls—including every U.S. president since Millard Fillmore." Known for serious quality without the serious attitude, Johnston & Murphy offers finely crafted shoes and boots for men and women, as well as quality leather accessories for men.

Reviews

(13)134.2 out of 5
Write a Review

Most helpful positive review

Feb 5, 2026

Pure Comfort

One of the most comfortable shoes I have ever slid my feet into. Right from the first slip-on, I was impressed by the comfort and feel of these shoes.
Gerry D
Verified purchase

Most helpful critical review

Mar 1, 2026

Good looking, bad finishing inside

Casual shoes look good, however finishing inside is bad. It is causing pain.
Arnold R
Verified purchase

Customer photos

Add your photo & review

Share your photo to help other shoppers.

5 stars62%
4 stars15%
3 stars8%
2 stars8%
1 star8%

Pros:

Cons:

Current reviews don’t mention any.
Aug 31, 2026

Good shoes for a while

Lasted about 18 months in the office then started to fall apart. The rubber in the sole is splitting across the ball of the foot. The leather is very comfortable and broken in, but the foam/rubber won't last much longer which is disappointing since the leather is really aging like you'd prefer.
DW
Mar 1, 2026

Good looking, bad finishing inside

Casual shoes look good, however finishing inside is bad. It is causing pain.
Verified purchase
Arnold R
Feb 5, 2026

Pure Comfort

One of the most comfortable shoes I have ever slid my feet into. Right from the first slip-on, I was impressed by the comfort and feel of these shoes.
Verified purchase
Gerry D
Jan 21, 2026

Anniversary McGuffey

I absolutely love these shoes. I have had several iterations of the McGuffey and this is by far one of my favorites. They are comfortable and I get tons of compliments on them. They only complaint I have is that they were out of stock on the blues ones.
Verified purchase
Don L.
Dec 4, 2025

Quality for 175!

Super comfortable and stylish. J&M never disappoints!
Verified purchase
JH
Oct 29, 2025

McGuffey 2 175th Anniversary Plain toe

I've been wearing J&M shoes for over 30 years and they rarely disappoint. I love these Anniversary shoes as they are very comfortable and stylish. I love the navy blue!
Verified purchase
David

Outfit Ideas For This Item